Hot KeyWords:CST8002D  CST6118  CST6508  XS9971   CST118S  CST2466  矽源特科技

Technology Exchange
You are here : Technology Exchange

Difference between triode and Mosfet

Views:113Time:2022-11-14
    "Bipolar transistor is a current control device (controlling a larger collector current through a smaller base current), and MOS transistor is a voltage control device (controlling the on resistance between source and drain through a gate voltage)."
    1. Working nature: triode is controlled by current, MOS is controlled by voltage
    2. Cost problem: triodes are cheap, MOS tubes are expensive.
    3. Power consumption problem: triode loss is large.
    4. Driving ability: MOS transistors are often used for power switches and switching circuits in places with high current.
    Triode is relatively cheap and convenient to use. It is often used in digital circuit switching control.
    MOS transistors are used in high-frequency and high-speed circuits, high current occasions, and places where the base or drain control current is sensitive.
    MOS tubes can be used not only as switching circuits, but also as analog amplifiers, because changes in gate voltage within a certain range will cause changes in on resistance between source and drain.


The main difference between the two is:
    Bipolar transistor is a current control device (controlling a larger collector current through a smaller base current), and MOS transistor is a voltage control device (controlling the on resistance between source and drain through a gate voltage).
    Under the on voltage drop of MOS transistor (field effect transistor), the on resistance is small, the gate drive does not need current, the loss is small, the drive circuit is simple, the self-contained protection diode has good thermal resistance characteristics, which is suitable for high-power parallel connection. The disadvantage is that the switching speed is not high and it is expensive.
    The switching speed of triode is high, and the IC of large triode can be very large. The disadvantages are large loss, large base driving current and complex driving.
    Generally speaking, for low-cost applications, triodes are considered first for ordinary applications, and MOS transistors are considered if not.
    In fact, it is wrong to say that current control is slow and voltage control is fast. To truly understand, we must understand how bipolar transistors and MOS transistors work.
    Triode works by the movement of carriers. Take the emitter follower of NPN tube as an example. When the base is applied with or without voltage, the PN junction composed of the base region and the emitter region prevents the diffusion movement of multiple electrons (the base region is holes and the emitter region is electrons). At this PN junction, an electrostatic field (i.e., an built-in electric field) pointing from the emitter region to the base region will be induced. When the base is applied with a positive voltage, the base region points to the emitter region, When the electric field generated by the applied voltage at the base is larger than the built-in electric field, the carriers (electrons) in the base region may flow from the base region to the emitter region. The small Zui value of this voltage is the forward on voltage of the PN junction (generally 0.7V in Engineering). However, at this time, there will be charges on both sides of each PN junction. At this time, if a positive voltage is applied to the collector emitter, the electrons in the emitter region will move to the base region under the action of the electric field (in fact, they all move in the opposite direction). Because the base region is very narrow, the electrons can easily cross the base region to reach the collector region and compound with the PN holes here (near the collector). To maintain balance, Under the action of the positive electric field, the electrons in the collector region accelerate the movement of the outer collector, while the holes move at the PN junction, which is similar to an avalanche process. The electrons at the collector return to the emitter through the power supply, which is how the transistor works.
    When the triode works, both PN junctions will induce charges. When the switch is in the on state, the triode is in the saturated state. If the triode stops at this time, the charges induced by the PN junction will return to the equilibrium state. This process takes time. However, MOS triodes work in a different way and do not have this recovery time, so they can be used as high-speed switches.
    (1) The field effect transistor is a voltage control element and the transistor is a current control element. When only a small current is allowed from the signal source, the field effect transistor shall be selected; Under the condition that the signal voltage is low and more current is allowed to be drawn from the signal source, transistors should be selected.
    (2) Field effect transistors use most carriers to conduct electricity, so they are called unipolar devices. Transistors use both majority carriers and minority carriers to conduct electricity. Which is called a bipolar device.
    (3) The source and drain of some field effect transistors can be used interchangeably, and the gate voltage can also be positive or negative. The flexibility is better than that of transistors.
    (4) Field effect transistors can work under very low current and voltage, and their manufacturing process can easily integrate many field effect transistors on one silicon chip, so field effect transistors are widely used in large-scale integrated circuits.
    (5) Field effect transistor (FET) is widely used in various electronic devices because of its high input impedance and low noise. In particular, using field effect transistors as the input stage of the entire electronic equipment can achieve performance that is difficult to achieve with ordinary transistors.
    (6) Field effect transistors are divided into junction type and insulated gate type, and their control principles are the same.
Other comparisons:
    1. The triode is a bipolar tube, that is, the inside of the tube is involved by two carriers, holes and free electrons.
    Field effect transistor is a unipolar tube, that is, when the tube works, either only holes or free electrons participate in conduction, and there is only one carrier.
    2. Triode is a current control device, and only when there is an input current can there be an output current.
    Field effect transistor is a voltage control device, and there will be output current without input current.
    3. The input impedance of the triode is small, and the input impedance of the field effect transistor is large.
    4. The source and drain of some FET can be interchanged, and the collector and emitter of triode can not be interchanged.
    5. The frequency characteristic of FET is not as good as that of triode.
    6. The noise figure of FET is small, so it is suitable for the preamplifier of LNA.
    7. If you want the current of the signal source to be small, you should choose a field effect transistor, otherwise, it is more appropriate to choose a triode.


    Disclaimer: This article is transferred from other platforms and does not represent the views and positions of this site. If there is infringement or objection, please contact us to del
    
中恒科技ChipHomeTek

Back Top